Low- and moderate-income (LMI) households are losing ground in the home purchase market, and the most recent data understates that decline because of how income levels are measured. This definition matters as the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) defines households based on one of four income levels. Many housing and financial policy discussions focus on low-income households (those making 50% or less of the median income for their community) and moderate-income households (those making 50% through 80%). The health of those families is a key measure of the community’s health. Middle- and upper-income households earn more than 80% and 120% of the median income, respectively.

The share of home purchase loans made to LMI families fell from 2020 through 2024, and then rose in 2025 when the method for measuring income levels also changed. This analysis draws on six years of NCRC lending data, and it is the third installment in NCRC’s 2026 Mortgage Market series.

The first installment in this series found that home purchase lending has held firm at about 2.9 million originations a year for three straight years. The second installment examined how race impacts which communities have access to the market and found that gains have not been evenly shared across racial groups. This piece reviews the same lending data with a different question in mind: what does it take financially to become a homeowner in today’s market?

Jason Richardson, Senior Director of Research

Resources

For the complete series, including videos, interactive visualizations and localized market analysis, visit our 2026 Mortgage Market series homepage. 

NCRC uses AI tools to assist with data processing, query development and report drafting. NCRC maintains full responsibility for the accuracy of all published analyses.

For customized community data requests or inquiries about membership benefits contact Ralph Cyrus (Membership Engagement Specialist) at rcyrus@ncrc.org.

Key Takeaways

1

Investors and upper-income buyers made up a growing share of home purchase loans, rising from 47.6% in 2020 to 51.0% in 2025.

2

Middle-income buyers’ share barely changed, holding at about 24% every year, while the low- and moderate-income share fell.

3

Low- and moderate-income borrowers’ share of home purchase loans fell from 27.1% in 2020 to 21.8% in 2024, then rose in 2025. The rise reflects a change in the income cutoffs used to classify borrowers. They have climbed faster than wages, so some borrowers who would have counted as middle-income in 2020 now count as moderate-income.

4

The national numbers understate what is happening locally. In Miami, FL, Providence, RI, New York City, Riverside, CA and Las Vegas, the share of buyers who are neither investors nor upper-income fell by nine to 13 percentage points, while in San Antonio, Myrtle Beach, SC, Austin, Boise, ID and Charlotte it moved in the opposite direction.

5

The estimated monthly payment on the typical purchase loan rose 96% from 2020 to 2025, while median buyer income rose 37% and median home value rose 39%.

The Market That Changed Under Buyers' Feet

The last six years of the mortgage market began with an extraordinary moment. In 2020 and 2021, 30-year mortgage rates fell to historic lows, far below the average of about 6% since 1990. Measured against that long-run average, those years were the aberration, not the norm. In past cycles, rising rates were usually met by cooling home prices, which kept monthly payments from rising. This piece’s lending data does not reach back far enough to show those earlier cycles directly. The comparison at the center of this article covers 2020 to the present.

The chart below indexes the 30-year mortgage rate, the monthly payment on the typical purchase loan, the value of the home and the overall consumer prices relative to their 2020 level:

Rates fell to record lows in 2020 and 2021, part of the decline in mortgage rates that fueled the housing boom. This drew buyers into the market with the cheapest financing in decades. The Federal Reserve’s response to rising inflation then pushed rates sharply higher, starting in 2022 where they have stayed since. Loan amounts and monthly payments kept climbing, far outpacing general inflation, with the chart above showing how wide that gap became. CoreLogic reported homeowners with a mortgage gained a combined $2.9 trillion in equity by the end of the second quarter of 2021, with Zillow’s research that year showing that repeat buyers drew on that equity to make stronger, often all-cash offers — a competitive edge first-time buyers had no comparable equity to match.

The pandemic drove a massive increase in internal migration as well. It reshaped geography as much as financing. Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies found that home prices in the least dense counties in the country grew faster than anywhere else between March 2020 and March 2023 — an unusual pattern researchers have tied to a pandemic-driven wave of remote work that let buyers move away from expensive urban cores and buy homes in lower-cost metros at historically low interest rates.

The rising prices that preceded higher interest rates were already driving up the costs for homebuyers. The Federal Reserve determined that declining home affordability was already curtailing home purchase borrowing among lower-income households as the pandemic recovery began in 2022. By 2025, the National Association of Realtors reported that first-time buyers made up just 21% of the national home mortgage market, the lowest share the survey has recorded since it began in 1981, down from roughly 40% before the 2008 financial crisis.

Low- and Moderate-Income Borrowers, 2020 to 2025

Home prices, monthly payments and the income needed to purchase a home all rose sharply since 2020. This section turns to the borrowers most exposed to that squeeze, those the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) classifies as low- or moderate-income. NCRC conducted an analysis last year based on lending trends by borrower and neighborhood characteristics. We found that LMI owner-occupied home purchase lending represented 25.8% of the market in 2024. The analysis extended that same measure through 2025 and also explored how often LMI applicants are actually approved for home loans.

The chart below shows the share of homebuyers each year for each of the four income ranges. The drop in upper-income borrowers in 2025 is partially explained by the methods used in determining who we call upper income.

The line between one income tier and the next is not fixed; it moves whenever the benchmark measuring area income changes. During the time period this data covers, that benchmark moved twice. The HMDA data shifted to its updated Census population boundary levels in 2022 with the federal government changing how it calculates the area income figure in 2025. Measuring today’s borrowers against the benchmark in place back in 2020 shows the effect directly, with both edges of the middle-income tier moving significantly. Roughly a fifth of the borrowers displayed in the chart above that were classified as moderate-income in 2025 earn enough that the 2020 benchmark would have called them middle-income instead. A comparable share of today’s middle-income borrowers would have been upper-income under that same 2020 line. The borrowers’ incomes are the same. Only the tier classification differs, because the thresholds moved for every borrower at once.

The chart below adds a second measuring point against the baseline trajectory, showing how much of that change comes from the benchmark moving rather than from buyers themselves:

The gold line is the share HMDA reports each year measured against that year’s shifting benchmark, which is also the same trend already shown in the chart above. The blue line uses those same real, rising borrower incomes but measures them against a single benchmark that held constant at its 2020 level. Measured against the constant 2020 benchmark, the low- and moderate-income share fell from 30.9% in 2020 to 22.2% in 2024 and barely changed in 2025. The reported share, shown in gold, rose by a much larger amount in 2025.

The gap between the two lines shows how much the 2025 comparison depends on the income benchmark, which makes 2025 difficult to compare with earlier years.

Loan applicants that the HMDA data classifies as low- or moderate-income were denied at roughly twice the rate as upper-income applicants in every year of this period, with the gap holding steady even as denial rates for both income groups rose and eased with the broader market. Getting approved has not gotten easier for LMI borrowers even in years where there were upturns in the market.

The national trend also hides sharp local variation. LMI share fell sharply in Providence, RI, New York City, Philadelphia and Las Vegas more than in almost any other large metro areas. It also grew in only a handful of the 50 largest markets, most notably San Antonio and Austin.

The chart below shows the actual dollar threshold amounts nationally along the following income levels: low to moderate, moderate to middle and middle to upper for each year in the 2020 to 2025 time period:

All three lines rise and fall together since each represents just a fixed share of the same underlying benchmark. The gains made for the middle/upper income group alone climbed from $94,600 in 2020 to $125,500 in 2025, nearly a third higher in just six years. The thresholds that define each tier moved substantially over this period. A family whose earnings barely changed can move from one income tier to another because the dollar cutoffs changed.

Five Numbers Behind a Home Purchase, 2020 to 2025

The last two sections of this brief show the cost of buying a home in today’s market as the overall share of low- and moderate-income buyers present in the market is shrinking. This section breaks down the lifespan of a single home purchase across the following categories —  the five real cost components, closing costs, the interest rate, the buyer’s income, the home’s price and the down payment — and tracks how each one progressed over the 2020 through 2025 time period. Down payment in this analysis is the home’s price minus the loan amount, which was calculated separately for each loan and then averaged across buyers. It’s not the difference between two already-averaged numbers, which gives a different and incorrect answer.

The chart below tracks all five numbers from 2020 through 2025:

This chart follows five costs that shape what it takes to buy a home. Each panel shows one of them for the typical buyer from 2020 to 2025: the closing costs paid at the table, the interest rate on the mortgage, the buyer’s income, the price of the home and the size of the loan. Each panel is drawn to its own scale, so compare how the bars move within a panel, not how tall they are next to another panel. Taken together, they show buyers facing more of everything. Homes cost more, loans are bigger and closing costs are higher. Incomes and home prices rose by similar amounts, so the number that changed most is the interest rate, which climbed sharply in 2022 and 2023 and stayed near its high through 2025.

The Typical Borrower, Then and Now

The chart below combines two groups into one share: upper-income owner-occupants and investors, measured against every home purchase loan made from 2020 to 2025. An upper-income buyer earns at least 120% of the area median family income. An investor is a buyer who used a mortgage to purchase a second home or an investment property.

HMDA records only purchases financed with a mortgage, so cash purchases do not appear in these figures.

Upper-income buyers and investors together moved from just under half of home purchase loans to just over half within a year, and they have stayed above that line since. The 2025 dip came in the year HUD changed how it sets area median income, so it should not be read as a reversal. The other side of that shift is the share of loans going to low- and moderate-income buyers, which fell each year through 2024 and then rose in 2025, a rise the same benchmark change makes hard to interpret. Even this understates the shift. HMDA records only purchases financed with a mortgage, so a purchase paid for in cash never appears in the chart. Investors pay cash far more often than other buyers with the National Association of Realtors reporting that more than half of investment buyers paid all cash in survey data covering roughly the first ten months of 2025. Counting those purchases would likely raise the share of homes going to upper-income buyers and investors well above half.

Metro Patterns

The national numbers mask enormous variation by metro area.

The table below shows how each of the 50 metro areas with the most home purchase loans in 2025 changed between 2020 and 2025. For each metro, it shows two things: the income of the typical buyer and the share of home purchase loans going to upper-income buyers and investors. A small line shows the trend year by year, and the change column shows how far each number moved. Click a column heading to sort the metros by the biggest changes.

The typical metro area moved at about the same pace as the national trend. Miami and Providence, RI saw the steepest declines, while a handful of Sunbelt metros like San Antonio moved in the other direction. The table above is sortable by this measure by clicking the Income Change or Investor and Upper Change column headers to see how any specific metros moved.

Only five of the 50 largest metros had ordinary buyers gain ground rather than lose it – Austin, San Antonio, Myrtle Beach, SC, Boise, ID and Charlotte, NC. None of these five metros overlapped with the country’s most expensive coastal markets, holding consistent with a pattern NCRC found in this year’s companion piece on race and the mortgage market; the highest-cost metros are where affordability pressure concentrates most.

National figures hide large differences between places. In Miami and New York City, ordinary buyers lost ground between 2020 and 2025, and the market they face now is very different from the one they faced then. In San Antonio and Boise, ID, ordinary buyers gained ground. The national average blurs that gap.

A more comprehensive overview for every metro, the charts featured and the definitions used in this piece can be found in the companion data workbook.

 

Mortgage Market Series

PART 3: The Shrinking Middle

Subscribe

Get NCRC news and
alerts by email.

Scroll to Top